top of page
Image by Augustine Wong

Digital sovereignty vs human rights: AI Governance in BRICS and the EU

11 minutes ago
4 min read

Written by Natalia Betancurt Cardona


Artificial intelligence (AI) has rapidly become an essential appliance of economic and geopolitical power, shifting the ways states govern data, technological innovation, and digital infrastructure. The concept of digital sovereignty, understood as the capacity of states to control digital resources and technological systems within their territory, has gained greater prominence in this evolving scenery.  While often framed as a necessary response to global competition and economic dependency, this transformation raises critical considerations regarding the protection of human rights in the digital era. 


This tension is particularly evident in the BRICS countries, where state-led strategies of technological evolution and governance are redefining the balance between individual freedom and sovereignty. Simultaneously, the regulatory landscape is evolving, with the European Union prioritizing the integration of fundamental rights into its Artificial Intelligence Act. Therefore, it led us to question: to what extent does the pursuit of digital sovereignty in BRICS countries reshape the protection of human rights in AI governance? And how is it comparable to the EU’s rights-based approach?


Photo: Alan Santos / PR (Palácio do Planalto), licensed under CC BY 2.0


Digital Governance and Human Rights in AI Governance 


Digital governance has developed into a fundamental principle in contemporary governance, mostly in the digital economy. It encircles state control of data flows, of digital infrastructure and technological standards. Often justified by strings with security, economic independence, and geopolitical influence.  Nevertheless, as global digital governance becomes increasingly defective, different regulatory frameworks serve as tangible manifestations of underlying ideological and political divisions. 


Existing research demonstrates that global digital regulation is already fragmentated and characterised by competing models, with major actors such as the United States, China, Brazil and India. This fragmentation extends to the normative level, dictating the equilibrium between market forces, sovereign authority, and individual rights.


AI governance is a defining human rights issue, threatening to eliminate privacy, amplify discrimination, and suppress expression. As decisions are increasingly made by automated data systems, oversight decreases, and people must rely on companies and governments that do not clearly explain how they operate. How governments govern this technology will define the future of human rights protection. 

 

The BRICS approach: Sovereignty and State-Centred AI Governance


Although there is a significant variation among the BRICS countries, internal policy divergences, AI governance is increasingly shaped by a shared ambition for national autonomy, economic strength, and enhanced state control over emerging technologies.


The struggle for digital supremacy in Asia highlights two distinct approaches to power. China’s centralized model merges technological efficiency with social control, dismantling private space in favour of state security. Meanwhile, India's trajectory is characterized by a high growth, yet legally ambiguous, landscape where surging innovation often outpaces the development of safeguards for individual expression.

Brazil presents a slightly different case, as the country implemented data protection through legislation based on international standards. In practice, rights are not protected effectively. This is due to institutional limitations and enforcement challenges.


Notwithstanding these differences, a common pattern is evident: AI governance is prioritized as a tool for economic growth, central state oversight, and strategic sovereignty. In this framework, digital technologies are treated less as subjects of rights-based regulation and more as critical, state-driven assets for augmenting national power.


Human Rights Implications 


The prioritization of national digital sovereignty in AI governance shows significant challenges to established human rights implications. First, privacy is increasingly threatened by large-scale data monitoring used for political goals,leaving individuals with very little influence over how their information is processed or shared. This approach actively erodes data privacy as a core fundamental right. Furthermore, the use of biased algorithms in law enforcement and social services erodes non-discrimination rights, all while lacking the transparency needed for proper accountability. Third, centralized digital architectures give states the power to silence expression and consolidate control. This trend risks downgrading human rights from non-negotiable legal duties to mere policy suggestions in an increasingly state-centric digital world.


Comparison with the European Union 


In contrast, the European Union has taken a leading role in regulating AI by putting human rights at the center of its approach, most notably through the AI Act. This framework sorts AI systems by the level of risk they pose to people’s rights and freedoms, and applies stricter rules to those with greater potential harm. By emphasizing transparency and holding institutions accountable, the EU shows a strong commitment to protecting fundamental rights in the age of AI. This creates a sharp geopolitical divide: While BRICS nations largely treat AI as a strategic tool for national sovereignty and rapid development, the EU views it as a domain that demands regulatory constraints. This fundamental disagreement is driving a fragmentation of the global digital landscape, where two competing philosophies, such as state power versus individual rights, exist without a clear path toward convergence.


In conclusion, the push for digital sovereignty among the BRICS countries is reshaping how AI is governed, shifting the focus away from individual rights and toward state-led development. In these systems, human rights are often treated as secondary to national security and economic independence. This approach contrasts sharply with that of the European Union, which seeks to “tame” technology by building legal safeguards directly into its rules. The comparison highlights a growing global divide: while the EU treats the law as a way to protect citizens, many BRICS countries use it as a tool to strengthen state control. As a result, the idea of universal digital standards is fading, replaced by a more fragmented global landscape.

In a world where states use technology to increase their power, can we still protect the individual, or are human rights becoming secondary to national interests? The answer depends on which model gains influence. Although the sovereignty-first approach is gaining ground, the EU’s rights-based model continues to serve as an important reference point, especially for democratic countries. There is still room for a middle path, one where technological progress does not come at the expense of personal freedom. However, if digital sovereignty is increasingly used to justify state control, individuals risk being reduced to little more than data points in a broader geopolitical struggle. 


Sources: International Organisations Research Journal, The African Journal of Information and Communication (AJIC), The Diplomat


Written by Natalia Betancurt Cardona

Edited by Tomás Díaz García and Olivia O’Mahony


 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page